Aboriginal health services concerned about lack of transparency in GP co-payment discussions

Print

Aboriginal health services today called on the Federal Government to consult more widely on the impact of the GP co-payment before it is put to the Senate.

The National Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation (NACCHO) Deputy Chairperson Matthew Cooke said the dealing apparently going on behind closed doors without input from the Aboriginal health sector was cause for concern.

“The fact is, the introduction of a GP co-payment is poor health policy for all Australians,” Mr Cooke said.

“Abolishing free universal health care will introduce a dangerous disincentive for people to seek the medical attention they need until their health conditions are advanced and need more invasive and costly attention.

“When applied to Aboriginal health its impact is likely to be magnified.

“We have made some gains in improving the health of Aboriginal people but we still have a long way to go to close the appalling health gap between Aboriginal and other Australians.

“We need our pregnant women to attend check ups, we need our children to be immunized, we need our young men to have access to mental health services.

“We simply can’t put any barriers in the way of Aboriginal people seeking health care or we risk the gains we are making in Aboriginal health. The GP co-payment is a significant barrier.”

Mr Cooke said speculation about exemptions from the GP co-payment for particular groups would only go part of the way to addressing the issues.

“Although we applaud the AMA’s efforts to work with the Federal Government to resolve the impact of a GP co-payment on vulnerable Australians, an exemption for Aboriginal Medical Services is not the silver bullet.

“The majority of our Services would have waived the co-payment for their patients, which would effectively have meant a cut in their funding, so in this regard it would be of benefit for our Services.”

“However, many Aboriginal people do not have access to Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Services because of where they live.

“There are 150 Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Services across Australia, providing primary health care to over half Australia’s Aboriginal population.

“But we don’t have national coverage so that would leave a lot of Aboriginal people using mainstream services still subject to the GP co-payment.”

Mr Cooke said he was also concerned about the additional pressures on Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Services if the exemption only applied to these Services.

“Demand for our Services is growing at a rate of about six per cent a year. Aboriginal people are already travelling large distances to seek out our Services as they prefer to be treated by someone who understands their culture and community.

“The co-payment exemption is likely to increase demand even further and would be a challenge for our Services to manage within their existing budgets and resources.”

Aboriginal heath services welcome back down on Racial Discrimination Act

Bernard Kelly-Edwards

The peak body for Aboriginal-run health services across Australia today welcomed the Federal Government decision not to proceed with the proposed harmful changes to the Racial Discrimination Act.

National Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation (NACCHO) Chairperson Justin Mohamed said it was proven that racism can have detrimental effects on the health of Aboriginal people. “We need as strong laws as possible in place to protect against racism,” Mr Mohamed said. “Racism can impact on self- esteem and confidence and ultimately contribute to poor mental and physical health. “We already have a high incidence of mental health issues in our communities and youth suicide rates which are the shame of the nation – five times higher than in non-Aboriginal young people. “We need to do everything in our power to ensure our people – both young and old – develop and maintain self-respect and positive identity. Racism undermines our ability to do this. “Racism should never be tolerated and it is little wonder communities across Australia have reacted so strongly against the watering down of provisions in the Racial Discrimination Act under Section 18C. “I am very pleased that the Federal Government has heard our call and changed their mind on this issue.”

Andrew Forrest: Aboriginal community controlled health sector is the single largest employer of Aboriginal people

PrintAndrew Forrest: Aboriginal community controlled health sector  is the single largest employer of Aboriginal people

The Forrest Review has missed an opportunity in not recommending the expansion of the Aboriginal Community Controlled Health sector as a pathway for employment, training and economic development for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, said the National Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation (NACCHO) today.

Responding the Forrest Review, NACCHO Chairperson, Justin Mohamed, said Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Services were leading, evidenced based examples for all governments to decrease unemployment, as the largest single employers of Aboriginal people, providing meaningful and sustainable training and career pathways.

Mr Mohamed did welcome recommendations to invest in and build the capacity of Aboriginal organisations to deliver their own services and to reduce the red tape that detracts from front-line service delivery.

However, he said he was concerned about the harsh measures around welfare detailed in the Report, questioning how this would improve Closing the Gap and the social determinants of health, and from a personal level improving Aboriginal self esteem or self-reliance.

“Aboriginal health services, operated by Aboriginal people, tick all the boxes for achieving better outcomes for Aboriginal people – health, training and employment,” Mr Mohamed said.

“They employ more than 3,500 Aboriginal people as doctors, specialists, nurses and administrators and, given the increasing demand for their services, have the potential to employ and train many more. In many cases they are the largest employers of Aboriginal people in the communities they service, and provide economic benefit to local and regional businesses.

“Better resourcing and an expansion of our sector would solve some of the issues relating to Aboriginal unemployment while improving the health of more of our people.

“It is disappointing the Forrest Review did not contain more about community driven models of employment such as those demonstrated by our Services.”

Mr Mohamed welcomed the Forrest Report’s focus on early childhood health and development and said Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Services were ideally placed to take this on.

“The Forrest reports notes the failure of mainstream services to address Aboriginal disadvantage.

“The fact is, most Aboriginal people prefer to go to a service that understands them and their culture. We are seeing evidence of this where families are driving large distances to visit our health services, bypassing many mainstream services on the way.

“Aboriginal parents will be more open to early intervention in their children’s health if the early intervention is being done by others within their own community.”

Mr Mohamed called on the government to support the Forrest Review’s recommendation for better accountability of government.

“The abolition of the COAG Reform Council means we don’t have that critical independent oversight of how we are tracking against the Closing the Gap targets. The development of the Implementation Plan for the National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Plan provides an opportunity to address this.”

Media contact: Olivia Greentree 0439 411 774

The Goanna Survey

nac-31-35-b-logo

Results of the first Australian study of knowledge, risk practices and health service access for Sexually Transmissible Infections (STIs) and Blood Borne Viruses (BBVs) among young Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people.

The final report presents the results of the first national survey of young Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people aged 16-29 years and comprises survey results from 2877 people.  The survey involved collection of data comprising four areas; (i) demographics; (ii) questions assessing knowledge of STIs and BBVs; (iii) questions relating to risk behaviours and (iv) questions related to use of and access to health services. Surveys were administered in every Australian jurisdiction. The project was initiated in 2010, and data collection occurred during 2011-2013. The survey was funded by an Australian Research Council Linkage Grant with contributions from State and Territory Health Departments. The survey was coordinated by peak Aboriginal health organisations in each jurisdiction and NACCHO.

Download Goanna Report July 2014

NACCHO Chair Justin Mohamed speech – NACCHO Health Summit 2014

justin_speech

As a Goorang Goorang man from Bundaberg QLD I would like to commence by formally acknowledging the traditional owners and custodians of land upon which we meet today and pay my respects to elders both past and present. 

Today my topic is ‘investing in community controlled health makes economic sense.

I don’t need to tell most of you in the room here today that putting resources into community controlled health can have a great impact: not only in closing the health gap between Aboriginal and mainstream Australia, but also in providing employment and training opportunities and  giving an economic boost to Aboriginal and mainstream communities.

Indeed we heard many great examples of this in the presentations and workshops yesterday. There is some amazing work being done across many critical areas within local Communities and I am looking forward to hearing more success stories as the Summit continues over the next two days.

We have all known that Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Services have a flow effect into their communities – indeed most people in this room would have seen it in action.

But at times it has had its challenges for us to provide the definitive proof when asked by policy makers or funders.

Which is why last year NACCHO commissioned research into the economic benefits of Community Controlled Health Services.

We wanted to have something tangible, something that clearly articulated what we were seeing in individual services every day, was a reality across all our services and across the Nation.

So we bought in respected health economist Dr Katrina Alford, where she spent time analysing the statistics that are publicly available, reviewing the data, talking to our services and compiling a comprehensive report which we were fortunate to have been invited to launch earlier this year at the National Press Club.

Of course the report showed just what we had thought it would – that the multiplier effect of our services in terms of employment, training and improving participation of our people is significant.

Our services are large-scale employers of Aboriginal people and in fact the main source of employment in many of our communities.

Lets take a look at a service, one used as a case study in the report – Mulungu.

Mulungi is in Mareeba in far north Queensland, on the Atherton Tablelands about an hour west of Cairns. Mareeba has a population of around 10,000 people and about thirteen per cent of those are Australia’s First Peoples.

Mulungi provides employment for 41 people in this small town, thirty being Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people from the local community. Aboriginal employment at Mulngu accounts for more than 12 per cent of all the Aboriginal employment in the area and wages and salaries in excess of $2.6 million a year

That’s a huge economic contribution, not just to the local Aboriginal community, but to the broader community of Mareeba.

Mulngu is not alone. Our 150 Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Services employ more than 5,500 people across the country and more than 3,500 of those are Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders.

That’s a very high number of people who have meaningful, secure jobs – participating in the labour market and in many cases effectively breaking the welfare cycle that can persist in some of our communities.

Further, these jobs are predominantly skilled occupations – Aboriginal Health Workers, doctors, nurses, health professionals, finance, IT, medical transport and administrative staff.

They provide wages and salaries that are much higher than the average Aboriginal Australian income which is use to support their families, take into their communities and boost regional economies.

The ripple effect of this employment cannot be underestimated and so our services are providing a solution to one of the key challenges we need to address if we are to reduce the chronic unemployment rates of our people.

Dr Alford’s report also found that alongside employment, Aboriginal Community Controlled health services provide extensive education and training opportunities for Aboriginal people.

Many of us here today, including myself can testify of the opportunities and experiences that were made available to many of us as younger Aboriginal & Torres Strait Islander men and women starting out our careers were given through our local Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisations.

This includes being mentored by inspiring, incredible and visionary Aboriginal people  – that taught us the importance of “Aboriginal health in Aboriginal hands”.

Learning on the job, raising educational levels and earning our stripes along the way. I doubt whether we could have achieved so much if it hadn’t been for opportunities and privileges to learn and be developed in such a nurturing and culturally sensitive environment.

Sadly however, although we are slowly seeing some improvements, many of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health workforce suffer institutionalized racism in the mainstream system and many have their career paths stunted.

Yet, in an Aboriginal Community Controlled Health environment, the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health workforce employees in the main flourish.

And as they do so they provide culturally appropriate, culturally safe, holistic health care which our people want to use.

They combine clinical know-how with culturally enriched local knowledge and wisdom.

We are seeing demand for our services rising at a rate of six per cent a year as more and more of our people seek our the care of the local services where they know they will be treated without judgment, but with respect and dignity.

People come to use our Services from far and wide – there are many examples of /Community members traveling many kilometres and considerable time to access our member services and in some cases by-passing mainstream health services on the way to our “culture centres of Comprehensive Primary Health Care”

 

Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisations

The trend toward Aboriginal people seeking check ups at their local Aboriginal Community Controlled Health service means we are starting to diagnose earlier, make real inroads into reducing risk taking behavior’s like smoking, and putting preventative health measures in place.

And as a result it is our services that are reducing child mortality by 66 per cent, and reducing overall Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander mortality rates by 33 per cent.

This in turn is slowly reducing the pressure and costs at the chronic end of the scale, reducing the need for hospitalisation and acute care.

And so again we see that our services are ticking numerous boxes in the struggle to close the gap between Aboriginal and white Australia:

Health – tick
Employment – tick
Training – tick.

Indeed, a single investment in Aboriginal Community Control Health Organisations deals with all three of the main challenges in Aboriginal communities:

  • High unemployment
  • Low education levels
  • And poor health

It is hard, then, to argue against the proposition that investing in Aboriginal community controlled health makes economic sense.

And yet we are still fighting for that investment.

It’s true that ACCHOs funding was renewed for 12 months just prior to the Federal Budget and that was welcome given the climate of spending cuts in all areas and particularly across the board in Aboriginal affairs.

But let’s face it – this is a long way short of what is needed – long term surety and security for our services and the large numbers of people they employ.

Plus many of the programs we run outside of the core funding are still up in the air. Indigenous health spending was cut by millions in the Budget and we are still waiting to see what that will mean for us on the ground.

The introduction of the medicare co-payment will hurt our services and given most will absorb the cost rather than pass it on to their clients, it will effectively result in a cut to their operating budget.

The next twelve months will be telling.

At NACCHO we will be fighting for five-year funding agreements, such as are given to the pharmacy guild, alongside a reduction in the masses of administrative red tape which divert many of services from providing care.

We will also continue to argue at the national level for ACCHOs to be exempt from any co-payments. We simply can’t afford for there to be any barriers to Aboriginal people seeking medical advice and seeking it early.

Introducing the co-payment will take us one step backwards and in Aboriginal health we need to keep moving forward or our gains will be lost.

We have worked hard over the years to develop our multi-partisan relationships with key decision makers at the highest levels and I believe we are getting some traction.

I take it as a positive sign that the Assistant Minister for Health Fiona Nash took up the invitation to speak at the Summit yesterday. She also said on the public record in a recent press release, and I quote:

“The Government recognises that while some improvements in Indigenous health outcomes have been achieved over recent years, there is still a long way to go to close the gap between the health and life expectancy of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people and non-Indigenous Australians.”

“The role that Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisations continue to play in the delivery of health services to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people is therefore vital.”

She may be convinced, but we are yet to see how this may be realised by other politicians, our collective job is to make sure every other Member of Parliament is also convinced, so when it comes down to a decision by the Treasurer on where he puts his funding, every Member of Parliament is an advocate for our movement of Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisations Programs, run by our member services for diabetes, chronic disease, smoking, maternal health and there is more,  we need local, state and federal decision makers to physically see our best practice models.

We have a goal over the next 8-10 months to have every MP visit their local ACCHO – see first hand what goes on in our services, to get a better sense of the great work that is being done in electorates across the country, and to see for themselves the real social and economic benefit of community controlled health.

Together we are a strong and powerful entity unmatched by any group or sector in this Nation. We as Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisations is the door for MP’s to gain first hand experience, so in this NACCHO has created an MP kit to assist in guideing on how to engage with local MP’s. Many already have long-standing relationships, but there are a number of newly elected MP’s and many more who may never have stepped inside an ACCHO.

If there is ever a time for our us to think and act strategically “with one voice” it is now.

We have the structure across local, State and National levels, we have great support from other State and National health bodies.  The next 3-6 months will prove to be nothing short of extreme importance not only for our member services today but into future years.

Aboriginal Controlled Health has proven over 4 decades that we are the vehicle in addressing Aboriginal Health and the cultural connection between clinical and traditional healing of the physical, emotional and spiritual wellbeing our our people.

 

 

 

 

Another step towards Indigienous Health Equality.

10338634_604344316339352_3048799585535217670_o

The Australian Government is taking another important step towards securing health equality for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people.

Assistant Minister for Health Fiona Nash has asked for work to begin on developing a plan for implementing the National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Plan.

“The implementation plan is about ensuring we deliver real outcomes on the ground,” Minister Nash said at the National Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation Summit at the Melbourne Convention and Exhibition Centre yesterday.

The Government is updating the Health Plan to reflect the Coalition’s approach and priorities in Indigenous affairs. In particular, the updated Plan will recognise the links between health and the key social determinants of education, employment and community safety.

“Higher education attainment, paid employment and safe communities are all connected with better health, and the Government is striving to ensure that these are delivered to improve the lives of Indigenous people nationally,” Minister Nash said.

“The Health Plan provides a useful framework to guide policy and programme development. However, Indigenous health will only be improved by concrete action on the ground.”

“The Government announced in the Budget that through a $94 million investment in Better Start to Life the Government will expand efforts in child and maternal health to support Indigenous children to be healthy and go to school”.

“The Government is committed to closing the gap by ending the cycle of disadvantage which starts with poor child health,” Minister Nash said.

“Focussing on the critical early years means Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children will get a positive foundation for life.”

As outlined in the Budget, the Australian Government will invest $3.1 billion in Indigenous specific health programmes and activities from 2014-15 to 2017-18 – an increase of more than $500 million compared to 2009-10 to 2012-13.

Aboriginal Health Summit: ongoing investment needed to close the gap

summit-2014-banner

Successes in improving the health of Aboriginal people, to be showcased over the next three days at an Aboriginal health summit in Melbourne, will highlight the importance of ongoing investment in Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Services and programs.

Justin Mohamed, Chair of the National Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation (NACCHO) said the 2014 NACCHO Health Summit will feature innovative and creative approaches to Aboriginal health, driven by Aboriginal people, which are achieving results.

“The Federal Budget has taken a huge chunk of funding out of Aboriginal health programs,” Mr Mohamed said.
“Given the incredible work being done by our sector to improve the lives of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, through prevention, early detection and health promotion, it simply doesn’t make economic sense to cut front line Aboriginal health programs.
“We still have a long way to go close the huge gap in life expectancy between Aboriginal and other Australians but we are on the right track to reaching our targets by 2031.
“It’s critical we maintain the momentum and continue to give Aboriginal people control over their own health – funding programs run by Aboriginal people – since that is where we will have the biggest effect.”
Mr Mohamed said some of the examples which will be shared at the 2014 NACCHO Health Summit include:
• The Victorian Aboriginal Health Services Healthy Lifestyles and Tackling Tobacco Team has implemented a range of different health promotion strategies to engage members of the community from children to elders in physical activity, quit and healthy lifestyles programs. Successful initiatives over the last 12 months include: fun runs, yoga, hypnotherapy, social marketing, a comedy show and more recently the VAHS Tram taking the Australian public along for the ride.
• Wuchopperen Health Service ‘Community Controlled Health Services have to prove their value contribution in an increasingly competitive landscape. Wuchopperen has survived three decades of funding uncertainty. Wuchopperen has enacted a multi-faceted strategy to ensure long term sustainability and self-determination – with self-sufficiency a possible endpoint within a decade. Leveraging MBS income streams Wuchopperen has facilitated an increase in staff numbers from 135 to 180 over three years, maintaining a proportion of 80 per cent Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Staff. All funds generated have been reinvested into further services to the community, including expanded allied health services and optometric care facilitating on-site eye-testing and dispensing of spectacles.’
• ABS presentation (funded by ABS/ Dept of Health/ National Heart Foundation) ‘The 2012-2013 Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Survey (AATSIHS) is the largest and most comprehensive survey of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander community ever undertaken. This survey provides a platform for a range of new research into health determinants and patters, supporting assessment of of progress in closing the gap in health outcomes.’
• Walgett AMS Accreditation Experience, Fifteen Years and Still Going Strong ‘In 1987 the CEO and Board of WAMS became concerned about changes to AMS funding conditions. In order to prepare for the possibility WAMS investigated agencies which accredited health services. In 2013 WAMS gained it’s fifth round of accreditation and in 2014 will work to bring it’s Dental Clinic into the process. Accreditation assists in improving client services and also enables the service to stand as equals with other Health Services and Medicare Locals’.
• John Patterson AMSANT CQI ‘The life expectancy gap between Aboriginal and other Australians in the NT is the widest in the nation, but it is also closing at the fastest rate. NT is the only jurisdiction on track to close the life expectancy gap by 2031. AMSANT believe that the implementation of the CQI programs has been pivotal to improving the Aboriginal PHC contribution to closing the gap.’
Mr Mohamed said “The summit will be the Centre of Excellence in Aboriginal Community Controlled Health and the best demonstration of Aboriginal Health in Aboriginal Hands.”
Media contacts: Olivia Greentree 0439 411 774 / Jane Garcia 0434 489 533

The Inaugural Fred Hollows Foundation Award

DRS-Award-Ver-6-Web-Res-1

Recognising Commitment to End Avoidable Blindness – Win A DRS Camera

Although Professor Fred Hollows died more than 20 years ago, his fierce determination and commitment to improving the eye health of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people lives on through The Fred Hollows Foundation. The Fred Hollows Foundation’s Indigenous Australia Program works with Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisations (ACCHO) and other eye health stakeholders to improve the eye health of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people living in remote and underserviced communities in Australia.

The Foundation is launching its Inaugural Eye Health Award to recognise the significant contribution of an ACCHO to improving Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people’s eye health.

THE AWARD – WIN A DRS CAMERA

Recipients of the award will receive a CentreVue Digital Retinography System – known as a DRS Camera – valued at $16,000. Onsite training on the installation, maintenance and use of the DRS camera will also be provided.
 
Download brochure for more information

NACCHO Health News – issue #2 hits this streets tomorrow!

The latest edition of NACCHO Health News (inserted in the Koori Mail) will be available in most newsagents around Australia from tomorrow, Wednesday 18 June. To view online please visit http://www.naccho.org.au/newspaper

Respectfully,

NACCHO Media Team

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander leaders call for scrapping of co-payments

PrintAboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Leaders from across Australia met in Canberra today for crisis talks regarding the implications of the Commonwealth Budget.

“The Aboriginal community sector will not agree to turn our backs on the most disadvantaged and disempowered,” said Julie Tongs, CEO of Winnunga Nimmityjah Aboriginal Health Service.”

“A coalition of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander organisations calls on the Australian Government to recognise that a co-payment is against the principles of health equity outlined in the Statement of Intent to Close the Gap in Indigenous Health Outcomes.”

“The suggested co-payments run counter to the findings of the World Health Organisation’s Commission on the Social Determinants of Health. Australia’s health policies and funding should reflect those findings.”

“Introducing co-payments will not serve to close the gap in health outcomes; it will only widen the gap between our people and the rest of the community,’ said Ms Tongs.

We reject the introduction of co-payments because they will increase inequality.

· Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people already experience considerable health disadvantage

· for every dollar spent on non-Indigenous Australians now, only 60 cents is spent on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people

· international evidence confirms the most efficient way to contain health care costs is a robust universal primary health care system

· the sustainability of Australia’s robust not for profit health sector, which currently supports the most vulnerable in our community, is threatened by this move.

Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Services and Aboriginal Medical Services:

· are the regular source of care for persons without social capital

· are an embodiment of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander self-determination

· represent a sound investment in not only health outcomes, but economic participation, employment and education for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people; the health industry is the single largest employer of Indigenous Australians.

“We are calling for an immediate scrapping of the MBS and PBS co-payments scheme.

“The Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health sector will not agree to turn our backs on the needy, disadvantaged and desperate.

“We welcome the opportunity to have further constructive conversations with government. We call on our partners, colleagues and all concerned Australians to stand with us at this critical time,” concluded Ms Tongs.

Contact: Julie Tongs, CEO Winnunga Nimmityjah Aboriginal Health Service Inc – 0418 206 156

 

 

The following agencies were represented at today’s meeting: VACCHO, AMSANT, Lowitja Institute, NACCHO, Winnunga Nimmityjah Aboriginal Health Service, NATSIHWA, AIDA, National Congress of Australia’s First Peoples, QAIHC and AHCSA. Also in attendance Public Health Association of Australia.